Stocks Down Despite Growth: Bonds Tell a Story

Advertisements

In recent days, the global financial markets have experienced turbulence, beginning with the United States, where major stock exchanges faced significant declinesThe technology sector, which had previously been a powerhouse, found itself particularly hard-hit, with the Nasdaq leading the downturn among the three main U.SindicesThis spillover of volatility has raised alarms among investors and analysts alike, pondering the underlying causes.

The focus has shifted toward the bond market, as the initial disruption became apparent with a sharp increase in bond yields—or more simply, a steep drop in bond pricesThis phenomenon left many retail investors and stockholders scratching their heads, as they struggled to comprehend the relationship between bond markets and stock performanceAfter all, they reasoned, they invest in stocks, not bonds; why should fluctuations in the bond market affect their holdings?

To grasp this intricate connection, one must first understand how the bond market operates

Although largely dominated by institutional investors and often perplexing to retail investors, the bond market holds colossal significance in the financial landscapeIn fact, the global bond market has historically surpassed the size of the stock market in terms of overall valueAs of late 2020, the total market capitalization of global equities approached $95 trillion, while the bond market soared to an impressive $128 trillion.

The overarching influence of government bonds, which represent the highest liquidity in the bond market, cannot be understatedThese bonds serve as an essential foundation upon which various financial metrics are builtFor instance, the yield on government bonds is typically regarded as the baseline risk-free rate that informs the pricing of other assets across the spectrumDuring moments of economic crisis, central banks frequently utilize government bonds in open market operations, such as quantitative easing (QE), to inject liquidity into the economy by purchasing these bonds.

This critical role of government bonds naturally cascades into how other financial instruments are priced

Essentially, all financial securities are priced based on projected future cash flows, which are discounted to reflect their present valueChanges in discount rates—which reflect the perceived risk of an asset—are pivotal in determining the value of these securitiesThe risk-free rate, anchored by government bond yields, constitutes the initial layer in this discounting processIf government bond yields rise, the discount rate for all other assets follows suit, leading to declines in present asset prices across board.

A prime example of this relationship can be seen with equities whose cash flows are highly uncertain and reliant on long-term growth projectionsStocks stand to be significantly more impacted by changes in bond yieldsThe further into the future an expected cash flow lies, the more pronounced the effects of discount rates become, thereby amplifying the volatility in stock prices

Therefore, it’s no surprise that when there’s a simultaneous rise in bond yields, stock valuations naturally suffer—especially for companies that lean heavily on high growth and future expectations, as their cash flows are further away and thus more susceptible to fluctuations in discount rates.

The emergence of a bear market appears to be rooted in both high growth and rising inflationHaving established how the bond and stock market interrelate, the next pressing question centers on the factors triggering the recent simultaneous rise in global bond yields.

The succinct answer revolves around market expectations: as the pandemic begins to show signs of abating, there’s a growing belief that the global economy will commence a robust recovery in 2021, accompanied by surging inflationIn essence, this means that expectations for economic growth catalyze declines in both the bond and stock markets.

This conclusion may evoke confusion, but it stems from a logical progression of events

alefox

Initially, when bond yields fell dramatically, it was due to a global economic upheaval caused by the pandemic, which led to plummeting GDPs across nationsIn response, vast amounts of capital flowed toward safe-haven assets—namely, government bonds that are devoid of default risks.

On the heels of this capital influx, central banks moved decisively to stabilize markets, instituting measures such as lowering interest rates and engaging in QE—actions that effectively drove bond prices up and yields downYet, as signs of recovery emerged, a collective shift away from the bond market by numerous institutions began to manifest, triggering declines in bond prices and upward pressure on yields.

One might be tempted to draw parallels with the post-2008 financial crisis scenario, where markets appeared less reactive to similar yield movementsHowever, key differences between the two crises illuminate why the current situation is distinct

The root causes of the 2008 crisis stemmed from fundamental flaws within the financial and economic systems, leading to prolonged recovery periods drawn out over several years due to factors such as the subsequent European debt crisisBy contrast, this recent crisis has emerged from an acute disruption caused by a global pandemic, engendering far swifter GPD contractions, yet providing an equally rapid trajectory for recovery, assuming the virus is kept in checkThe recovery in economies like Australia, which successfully managed the pandemic, underscores this potential trajectory.

Most importantly, divergent expectations surrounding inflation have led to markedly different outlooks on monetary policy and market interest ratesPost-2008 financial conditions were characterized by persistent stagnation, exacerbated by the European debt crisis, resulting in a protracted period where central banks engaged in unprecedented policies, including negative interest rates

While inflation struggled to gain traction then, the prevailing sentiment now points toward a swift rebound in consumer demand post-pandemicConcomitantly, critical sectors such as manufacturing and international trade—which are vital for economic recovery—are expected to take longer to normalize, nurturing a likely scarcity and fueling market expectations for inflation to spike.

Consider the situation in Australia: at the end of December, prices for standard consumer goods surged dramatically—largely attributable to rising oil prices coupled with housing costsHowever, as of early 2021, the escalating international oil prices compounded by rampant housing values have fostered an environment where consumer product prices show no signs of abatingThis dynamic portends a period of high inflation for the foreseeable futureWith diminishing demand for bonds as a safe haven and yields trending above expected inflation rates, the logical trajectory would see yields rise, alongside a decline in bond prices, which would subsequently lead to a broader sell-off in all securities.

Does this market trajectory imply a foreboding bear market looming on the horizon, as global financial markets may continue their downward spiral? Not necessarily; there are vital counterpoints to consider.

Firstly, the prevailing economic landscape leans toward recovery and rebound

As long as this underlying trend remains intact, the fluctuations we observe in bond yields should stabilize, aligning with normalization in market ratesUltimately, this period may represent a necessary recalibration of valuations rather than the onset of an economic crisisAs the market adjusts from prolonged periods of artificially low interest rates, equities should begin to reflect growth in economic activity and accompanying corporate profits, moving the market away from a potential crash.

Secondly, central banks will likely maintain a critical interventionist role in the futureDespite signs of pandemic recovery, most countries have not regained complete economic orderConsequently, decision-makers are unlikely to exacerbate risks to the financial system until full control over the pandemic is establishedMany central banks will continue their buying programs in the market to manage fluctuations; for example, the Reserve Bank of Australia recently clarified its intention to increase daily bond purchase limits as a counter measure to bond market volatility.

In summation, the turbulence currently gripping the markets can be attributed to clear dynamics: the promise of a recovering economy spurred by an end to the pandemic, coupled with a faster-than-usual recovery leading to inflationary pressures amid an ongoing challenge in industrial production and supply chains

As these forecasted shifts unfold, growing yields and declining bond prices lead to heightened discount rates applied to all securities, resulting in widespread price drops, particularly in riskier equities.

Nevertheless, ecosystem vigilance remains vitalInvestors need not overreact, as long as economic recovery remains unimpeded by market fluctuations; ultimately, the increase in corporate profitability spurred by economic growth will outweigh the short-term challenges posed by emerging normalized bond yield environmentsFurthermore, given the nascent stages of recovery and the unlikely stance of central banks to remain entirely passive amidst escalating volatility, there exists ample motivation to intervene, potentially smoothing the rise in interest rates.

The analyses and viewpoints expressed in this article are not intended as trading advice; they merely serve as a reference point

Add Comment